• Are we doing this because it is inherently good, or as a means to an end? If the latter, what end?
• Does it encourage the student to think of education itself as a high and noble enterprise, or does it cheapen education?
• Is it excellent? Does it demand the best students and teachers have to offer, and hold them to the highest standard they are capable of achieving? Or does it give in to the gravitational pull of mediocrity?
• Is excellence the highest standard, or is excellence subordinate to lower standards such as convenience or popularity?
• Does it encourage reverence for the mystery of God and the splendor of His creation?
• Does it encourage reverence for the mystery of the human person and respect for the student’s own human dignity?
• Does it encourage the student to desire truth, to understand such virtues as courage, modesty, prudence, and moderation and to cultivate these internally?
• Does it help the student to see what difference God makes to all the facets of the world, or does it make God’s existence seem irrelevant, trivial, small or private?
• Does it assist in passing on the received wisdom of the Christian tradition, or does it create obstacles to reception of the tradition?
• Does it encourage real searching and thinking? Does it provoke the student to ask ‘why?’ Does it stir up a desire for understanding?
• Does it encourage conversation between and across generations or does it hinder it?
• Does it help to develop to the fullest extent what is uniquely human in the student: the powers of attending, deliberating, questioning, calculating, remembering, and loving?
• Does it encourage the student to become patient, to take time, and if necessary, to start over in order to achieve excellence, or does it subordinate excellence to speed, ease, and efficiency?
• Does it encourage the student to value rigor and discipline?
• Does it deepen the role of the family in the life of the school and the role of education in the life of the family, or does it erect a barrier between family and school?